CHAMA CHA MWANANCHI, SOCIALIST

KENYA’S LEADING SOCIAL DEMOCRATS

Archive for April, 2008

Suspected robber shot dead, SHOOT TO KILL POLICY

Posted by SG on April 30, 2008

Suspected robber shot dead

Written By:Nicholas Kigondu   , Posted: Tue, Apr 29, 2008

Police in Nairobi Tuesday morning shot dead a suspected gangster after a robbery attempt along the city’s Tom Mboya street.

The suspect in the company of two others is said to have way laid a businesswoman who had withdrawn forty thousand shillings from a bank before violently robbing her of the cash.

Confirming the incident, Central OCPD Tito Kilonzi said police responded to the victim’s alarm shooting dead the suspect.

However his two accomplices managed to escape.

Other reports say over sixty families in Mukuru kwa Njenga slums were Tuesday morning left homeless after a fire razed down their houses.

The early morning inferno is said to have started from one of the houses before spreading to adjacent structures.

Area chief David Ikigo blamed the incident on illegal power connections.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

STOP CHILDISH POLITICAL GAMES

Posted by SG on April 30, 2008

Bickering over primacy adds little value to governance

Story by LUKOYE ATWOLI
Publication Date: 4/30/2008

THE PAST FEW DAYS HAVE seen Kenyans being treated to an unsavoury manifestation of the power-play that is at the very root of this country’s recent dalliance with disintegration.

Politicians, academics and common citizens have exercised their minds on who between Prime Minister Raila Odinga and Vice-President Kalonzo Musyoka is more powerful than the other.

The feud has been prosecuted in the full glare of publicity and has even come in the way of the Government’s own efforts at reconciliation.

The issue has become so emotive that it has become the proving ground for idle loyalists still stuck in the pre-election campaign mode.

Every politician is seeking to prove just how loyal he or she is by shouting loudest about their man being the closest to the seat of power.

THE TRAGEDY IS THAT THESE people are all supposed to be serving in the same government and working towards better service delivery for Kenyans.

Their two ‘‘Principals’’ signed an agreement, which the MPs then endorsed in Parliament and entrenched in the Constitution. The continuing wrangles over who is the most powerful between the PM and the VP, therefore, exposes the politicians’ ignorance over the contents of the Bills they passed at the height of the crisis.

After passage of the political agreement, Parliament was supposed to turn its attention to the more pressing matter of long-term solutions, including a review of the Constitution, land reforms and institutional reforms to fashion Kenya into a modern state with clear guidelines on what is acceptable and what is not.

Parliamentarians were supposed to take the lead role in reconciling our warring communities and creating a framework for lasting peace through truth, justice and reconciliation.

Instead, they spend their waking hours wondering how to prove their might to the ‘‘other’’ side. Even straightforward issues such as resettlement of internally displaced persons have become mired in the petty political squabbles and mistrust that pervades our political space.

When the National Accord was signed late February, it was argued in these columns that the hard work was only just beginning. It was pointed out that the celebrations were all premature. These arguments are now being clearly borne out by the petulant chest-thumping our politicians are now displaying.

It can now be surmised that for the politicians, it is back to business as usual. In their minds, Kenyans cannot have enough of politics, and every day is another day on the campaign platform, seeking to out-perform the political or ethnic ‘‘other’’.

The clamour for a new Constitution has been abandoned for the next big thing, in this case the row over primacy between the PM and the VP.

Dealing with the food crisis can wait, so that the President can clarify who is second to him. Our discredited electoral system can wait until one of the men is confirmed in no uncertain terms to be the most important.

What is emerging is that as long as we put our hopes in the current crop of politicians (or indeed any politician) we are doomed to keep repeating the mistakes of the past.

Like the proverbial lunatic, we will keep doing the same thing over and over, and expecting a different result with each repetition. These ‘‘leaders’’ are failures even before they begin doing whatever it is they are supposed to be doing for their electors.

KENYANS ARE THEREFORE CALLED  upon to begin searching for a new leadership paradigm that does not include excellence in politics or astuteness at accumulating wealth by stealing from the poor.

Today, our public service is on the verge of collapse due to the sheer weight of incompetence and lack of vision that chokes the entire governance system.

The poorest carry the weight of the rich, and when they grumble, they are told to wait a while longer while their terms are being looked into.

The true leader stands at the head of the column, not at the rear. Our leaders must stop these childish games and face up to the challenge of leadership.

This demand for leadership is even more urgent at the top than anywhere else in this country. Our very survival as a nation depends on it.

Dr Atwoli is a consultant psychiatrist working in Eldoret (lukoye@gmail.com)

 
Write to the author

Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

GRAND POVERTY DUE TO GRAND CABINET

Posted by SG on April 30, 2008

Kenya: Grand Cabinet to Cost Sh33bn in Two Months

 

The Nation (Nairobi)
 

Email This Page

Print This Page

Comment on this article

Jeff Otieno And Benard Namunane
Nairobi

Taxpayers will pay Sh33 billion to fund the grand coalition Cabinet in the next two months alone.

Some of the money will be shifted from programmes with major social implications, including the building of new hospitals and road rehabilitation.

The programmes had been factored into the Budget for the current financial year which ends in June.

The high cost of managing the expanded Cabinet became clear in a mini-budget presented by Finance minister Amos Kimunya in Parliament Tuesday..

Besides shifting money from key programmes, the Government will have to come up with new measures to raise an extra Sh22.3 billion to meet the costs of running the new ministries and pay for other priority needs, including resettling internal refugees and mitigating against the effects of post-election violence.

The appointment of a record number of 42 ministers in the grand coalition formed by President Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga ignored calls by civil society and other groups for a lean Cabinet.

Endorse estimates

Parliament is expected to endorse Mr Kimunya’s estimates to enable the new ministries carry out their functions before the next Budget is read in mid-June.

The extra funds will finance the new office of the Prime Minister, which is to get Sh243.9 million as recurrent vote and 183.4 million for development, bringing the total to Sh427.3 million.

The PM’s office, whose role is to supervise and coordinate government affairs, was created after the signing of the National Accord that allowed for power-sharing between President Kibaki’s PNU and Mr Odinga’s ODM.

The President had already appointed 17 ministers from PNU and its partners in Kanu and ODM Kenya, but then expanded the Cabinet to incorporate the former opposition ODM. This made it necessary to split several ministries and create some new ones.

Among the entirely new dockets are the Ministry of Nairobi Metropolitan Development headed by Mr Mutula Kilonzo, which gets Sh41.5 million, and the Ministry of Development of Northern Kenya and other Arid Lands, headed by Mr Ibrahim Elmi Mohamed that gets Sh42.4 million for recurrent expenditure and Sh1.8 billion for various projects.

Most of the others were split from existing ministries. They include the Forestry and Wildlife ministry that will need Sh3.2 billion to pay salaries and other expenses and Sh1.5 billion as development expenditure

The Medical Services ministry headed by Prof Anyang’ Nyong’o has been allocated Sh102.2 million as recurrent expenditure. It has not been allocated funding for development. It was formerly part of the Ministry of Health.

The Ministry of Industrialisation headed by Mr Henry Kosgey is to get Sh1.17 billion as recurrent and Sh503 million for its development expenditures. Some of the money is expected to come from the Trade ministry under Deputy Prime Minister Uhuru Kenyatta. He will be asked to surrender Sh950.9 million.

And the Ministry of Fisheries, which was hived off the Ministry of Livestock and Fisheries Development, has asked for Sh717.9 million as recurrent and Sh213 million as development expenditure.

The Ministry of Public Works, which was split from the Roads ministry, will need Sh791.7 million as recurrent expenditure and Sh1.7 billion for various projects countrywide.

New roads

In the development budget, money allocated to roads will be reduced by Sh2.58 billion, meaning that rehabilitation and construction of new roads is likely to be affected for the next two months.

To fund the new ministries, the Government had to reduce money allocated to some key ministries with the major casualty being Education whose recurrent expenditure will be reduced by Sh9.8 billion if approved by Parliament.

The Ministry of Finance, a key player in preparing the mini-budget, will lose Sh3.2 billion from its recurrent expenditure estimates, while the Ministry of Environment and Mineral Resources, headed by Mr John Michuki will lose Sh2.1 billion from its recurrent vote, probably reallocated to the new Ministry of Forestry and Wildlife.

The State Law Office, whose core duty is to formulate Bills, new laws and regulations will be required to give up Sh150 million from its current budget. The recurrent budget for the National Assembly will be reduced by Sh384 million.

Another Sh284 million will come from the recurrent budget for the Ministry of Special Programmes, while the Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission’s budget will be reduced by Sh37.3 million.

The Ministry of Roads will also have to do with a reduced budget as it will be required to surrender Sh550 million after creation of a separate Ministry of Public Works.

Relevant Links

The Ministry of Tourism, which has surrendered Wildlife docket, has been asked to return 66.8 million from its recurrent budget. This could affect marketing strategies even as the industry seeks to recover from the effects of post-election violence.

The Information ministry will give up Sh29.9 million from its recurrent budget.

Afforestation will also be affected because the development budget for the Ministry of Environment will be reduced by Sh1.1 billion.

Posted in News | 1 Comment »

NO MERCY TO THOSE BEHIND KILLINGS SAY KARUA

Posted by SG on April 30, 2008

Karua rules out amnesty

Story by WILFRED MUCHIRE
Publication Date: 4/29/2008

There will be no amnesty for those involved in post-election violence.  And no pre-conditions should be set before internal refugees were resettled, stated Justice, National Cohesion and Constitutional Affairs minister Martha Karua at the weekend.

The minister said those agitating for talks before settlement were wasting their time. “Some people have been calling for forgiveness of those arrested but I want to say that the due course of law must take charge,” she said.

Ms Karua was speaking on Sunday at AIPCA Kiriti Church in Tetu, Nyeri South, where she presided over a funds drive for the institution’s theological college.

She said if amnesty was granted, people would also demand the release of people arrested on other grounds.

“In central Kenya, young men have for the last two years or so been arrested for being members of the outlawed Mungiki sect. Local leaders will demand for their release also if some leaders are allowed to have their way,” she said.

The minister said instead of calling for amnesty, the leaders should demand speedy expedition of the cases so that the innocent can be released.

“What we should have is expediting of cases so that the innocent can be set free.

“The law also provides for reconciliation where parties agree and this can also be applied. The leaders should have faith in our laws,” Ms Karua said.

Historical injustices dated back to the colonial days, she noted, and every region had issues to raise when the time comes.

“Thousands of people are suffering in camps and there is nothing to discuss before they are back in their farms. Historical injustices affect all and will be addressed in due course,” she said.

She blamed the founders of the nation, saying the problems currently gripping the country could have been settled when the country was still young.

Standards

The rule of law must always prevail, she maintained and hit out at those calling for the disbandment the Electoral Commission of Kenya.

“If ECK is bad as some people want us to believe, why do they allow themselves to be called members of Parliament and yet they were declared by the same body? ECK commissioners have security of tenure and no matter what some want, the law must be obeyed,” she said.

Ms Karua reiterated she would be gunning for the top seat in future.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

POLICE KILLS 2 MUNGIKI LEADERS HEADED FOR A PEACE MEETING

Posted by SG on April 30, 2008

Kenya: Mungiki, Govt Meeting Aborts

 

The East African Standard (Nairobi)
 

Email This Page

Print This Page

Comment on this article

Cyrus Ombati
Nairobi

The killing of two top Mungiki leaders has sent the sect into a panic and forced its members to abandon a high-level reconciliatory meeting that had been planned for Naivasha on Tuesday.

The meeting would have been the first formal contact between members of the banned sect and the Government, as proposed by Prime Minister Raila Odinga two weeks ago.

Although it was not clear who had convened the meeting, a senior Catholic bishop and a former Provincial Commissioner were expected to meet top Mungiki leaders and listen to their grievances. This would then have been passed on to the authorities.

Police confirmed to The Standard that the Catholic bishop and former PC were to attend the Naivasha meeting, which other sources said was an attempt by the authorities to reach out to the proscribed sect.

But following the Monday killing of the two Mungiki leaders on the Nairobi-Naivasha Highway, the sect’s leadership immediately saw a red flag over the Naivasha retreat. They suspected that the ‘meeting’ could be a set-up to arrest or shoot them dead.

The two leaders – acting chairman of Mungiki’s political wing, the Kenya National Youth Alliance, Charles Ndung’u Wagacha and treasurer Naftali Irungu – were executed in cold blood in broad daylight as they sped towards Naivasha Maximum Prison.

They were felled by bullets from unknown gunmen in a Hollywood-style shooting near Uplands Shopping Centre after being trailed from the Limuru area at about 1pm on Monday.

But families of the slain men pointed an accusing finger at the police, saying they had previously received threats against their children’s involvement in sect activities.

Before the meeting aborted, the first batch of the Mungiki representatives had already arrived in Naivasha town and proceeded to visit their national leader, Maina Njenga, at the Naivasha Maximum Prison.

But after the highway killings, the members chickened out, with their spokesman saying they could not go on with the meeting because Government agents were after them. The official said they were consulting from their hideouts before they could “come out again”.

No factions

There were reports that the bishop and the former PC managed to visit Maina Njenga at the Naivasha prison, where they held a lengthy meeting.

That notwithstanding, top Mungiki leadership has discounted theories that the ongoing killings and abductions were being staged by a renegade faction.

Njenga – who spoke through a trusted aide – and former leader-turned-pastor Ndura Waruinge said there were no internal divisions amongst them, saying the sect leadership was intact.

The sect spokesman, Mr Njuguna Gitau Njuguna, also denied the claims, terming them police propaganda. He said police were doing so to avoid answering questions on those behind the mysterious killings.

Waruinge said he was confident, from his past experiences with Mungiki, that the sect was still united.

“I was there and I know what Mungiki is. They are united and loyal and will not be divided. Those who are trying to drag my name into the saga are lying,” said Waruinge.

Police have repeatedly said that emerging divisions within Mungiki were behind the recent killings targeting their top leadership.

The divisions revolve around the control of the sect leadership and resources after Njenga was jailed for five years over drug and firearm possession.

Investigators say two camps, one led by Njenga and the other by Waruinge, are fighting each other, hence the recent killings.

Waruinge called The Standard newsroom to deny the claims, saying he had left the movement long time ago.

“I think that is propaganda being spread by the police. Why can’t they arrest those killing other people then if they think there are camps? I am not in the movement any more and I do not think the theory is true,” said Waruinge.

Waruinge announced two years ago that he had quit the movement to preach the word of God.

On his part, Njenga said Mungiki was still intact and determined to soldier on. He said the split theory was being fronted by the police to cover up their illegal activities.

“This is a religious group with rules to be followed and there cannot be two camps at all. We are united and peace loving people,” said Njenga.

Other Mungiki leaders said at least 20 of their followers have been killed since January and blamed police over the same.

The Monday killing of Mungiki leaders was the second high-profile death to plague the sect leadership in recent months. The bodies of Njenga’s wife – Virginia Nyakio and her driver George Njoroge – were found dumped in a forest in Gatundu on April 9.

Their killings sparked violent riots that saw 14 people killed and public transport paralysed in several parts of the country for almost a week.

The slain Wagacha was the elder brother of Nyakio’s driver, Njoroge, who is yet to be buried. The killing also came days after two other Nairobi leaders went missing from their areas of residence.

Ndung’u’s parents accused the police of killing the two and demanded justice.

“I know they are the ones who killed my sons. I’m sure of that because they have been warning me that my sons will be killed if they continued to follow Mungiki doctrine,” said Ndung’u’s mother Mrs Esther Wanja.

Ndungu’s father, Mr Joseph Wagacha, a retired Chief Inspector of Police, said he believed police had a hand in the killings.

“Why can’t they arrest them and take them to court if they know they are Mungiki members?” posed senior Wagacha.

The parents said they did not know how they would take care of eight children left behind by the deceased brothers.

Wanja said four police officers had visited their Mai Mahiu home last year, and warned her that her sons would be killed if they did not abandon the sect.

Relevant Links

The parents, who visited Lari Police Station to view the vehicle Ndung’u was killed in, however refused to comment when asked whether or not their sons were followers of the banned sect.

The mother of five said she knows the police officers were from Nairobi because they had visited her home to demand logbooks of their vehicles.

She said her late son (Ndung’u) had called her on Monday morning to inform her that they were headed for a meeting with the former PC in Naivasha but did not elaborate. She was later called to be informed that her son had been shot dead alongside his friend.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

KENYANS NAMED FOR LEADERSHIP

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

Six Kenyans named to Africa Leadership Initiative

Written By:Nationmedia   , Posted: Sun, Apr 27, 2008

Six Kenyan professionals have been named to this year’s class of the prestigious Africa Leadership Initiative – East Africa Foundation.

They will join 18 other representatives from Tanzania, Uganda, and Rwanda who will ultimately be expected to use their entrepreneurial talents to address the major challenges facing their organisations, communities and the countries they live in.

This initiative is part of the Aspen Global Leadership Network which includes  more than 700 fellows from 36 countries.

It also brings together business executives and professionals under 55 who have already achieved remarkable success in their chosen fields.

The fellows will meet four times over a two-year period and will undertake individual community service commitments.

The Kenya’s representatives include Mrs Julie Gichuru, a News Anchor, Mrs Rose Ogega, Finance Director Skynet Worldwide Express, and Mr Patrick Obath, MD and Country Chairman, Shell and BP Kenya, Mr Salim Amin, CEO Camerapix Limited, Mr Martin Kimani,  senior counter-terrorism advisor at IGAD in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia and Mr Muchiri Wahome, CEO, Deacons Kenya Ltd.

Representatives from Tanzania include Mr John Ulanga, the Executive Director, Foundation for Civil Society, Mr Aidan Eyakuze, economist and co-founder Serengeti Advisers, and Mr Nehemia K. Mchechu, the CEO, Commercial Bank of Africa, Dar es Salaam, Ms Vickie Chale, human resources consultant, Mr Heri Bomani, CEO, Kenya Commercial Bank, Tanzania, and Ms Kati Kerenge, head of marketing and corporate communication, Simba Cement Company Ltd.

Uganda is represented by Mr Robert Kabushenga, CEO, New Vision Printing and Publishing Company, Mr Oskar Semweya, school administrator Taibah Schools and Mrs Nora Owaraga, CEO, Executive Support Services, Kampala, Mr Ssebbale Kato, a surgeon and medical entrepreneur, Mr Paul Kavuma, director and head of East Africa Actis Private Equity in Nairobi and Mrs Maria Odido Di Fozo,  managing director, Bee Natural Products Factory, Kampala.

Representatives from Rwanda include Mr Henry Gaperi, CEO Rwanda Social Security Fund, Mr John Mirenge, (MD Electrogaz), Mr Patrick Kabagema (MD, Rockglobal Consulting) and Mr Richard Mugisha, founder and managing partner, Trust Law Chambers, Kigali, Mr Mutoni Kayihura, MD, Contact One Centre and Mrs Monique Nsanzabaganwa, Minister for Trade and Industry.

Mr Ali Mafuruki, the Ínitiative’s East Africa Foundation chairman aho announced the names said the fellows represent the region’s hope for a better future where ethics and values will play a central role in the decision making process.

“We are delighted with this year’s class of ALI Fellows, the second in East Africa since the year 2000,” Mr Mafuruki said. “With all the leadership challenges that are playing out around us in the region and all over the world, the launch of this class could not have occurred at a better time.”

The initiative is a collaborative project of seven partner organisations in Africa and the United States.

They include the US-based Aspen Institute and TechnoServe, CETA Construction Services (Mozambique), Databank Foundation (Ghana), Infotech Investment Group Limited (Tanzania), LEAP Africa (Nigeria) and Letsema Foundation (South Africa).

There are some 200 Fellows from Tanzania, Nigeria, Ghana, South Africa, Mozambique, Kenya, Uganda and Rwanda.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

KIBAKI RAILA USELESS TOURS

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

What, exactly, did the tours achieve?


Publication Date: 4/28/2008

The last week ended on a high note, with generously publicised tours of camps hosting internally displaced people by the President and Prime Minister, during which they preached ethnic tolerance and insisted that refugees be resettled in their former lands and homes.Of course, that is easier said than done. The long-overdue tours were a welcome sign that, indeed, the Government was taking the issue very seriously.

However, to ensure the visits do not turn out to be mere public relations exercises, the outcome should be accorded similar prominence.

In other words, the refugees, and Kenyans in general, want to know what, exactly, was achieved by those tours, and whether it has been decided exactly when they will be resettled.

This is no idle concern. The recalcitrance displayed by some legislators from the area is worrying, for by insisting on a set of conditions being fulfilled before the refugees are resettled, they are sending clear signals to their voters that those refugees who do return will be unwelcome.

This is not to be tolerated. The majority of these people cooped up in makeshift camps are innocent of any wrongdoing. Why should they rusticate there for months on end so that some nebulous ‘‘historical injustices’’ can first be  rectified? And why should the MPs  behave as though Rift Valley is not part of Kenya and therefore not subject to the laws of the land?

The Government must take a firm line on this issue. The very callous statements should be regarded as incitement to violence and the full force of law applied against them.

A fitting punishment should be, perhaps, for the noisiest of them all to spend at least one day in a camp, and then they would appreciate what it means for a Kenyan to be turned into a refugee in his or her own country. However, this is not to say the issues raised are not genuine. All we are saying is that the MPs should join the efforts to preach peace and then agitate for the rectification of those injustices.

 
Write to the author

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

political realities on the ground

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

Of protocol and political realities on the ground

Published on April 28, 2008, 12:00 am

By Dominic Odipo

I was watching television the other day when I saw President Kibaki stop, bend and peer into one of the tents housing internally displaced people (IDPs) at the Eldoret Showground.

About ten seconds later, I saw him straighten up again with a pained look on his face.

I noticed also that the President made no attempt to enter the tent (it was empty). Literally, he did not get onto the ground inside the tent. He left without getting the real feeling of what IDPs are going through.

Here was the President acting as he so often does: He remained, or seemed to remain, above the fray.

When the President saw those thousands of IDP tents at that showground, did it immediately strike him why those tents were there?

Bungled elections

Did it strike him that these IDPs were living in such deplorable conditions because of the manner in which the Electoral Commission of Kenya had bungled last year’s presidential elections?

Did it strike him that if the presidential votes had been counted and tallied openly and announced in broad daylight, those tents would not be there? Might it have struck him that his sudden and precipitate swearing-in at State House, Nairobi (instead of Uhuru Park as in 2003) was one of the major reasons why these tents were there?

Shortly afterwards, the presidential party arrived at the Kipchoge Keino Stadium and the entire nation was treated to an extremely fascinating and revealing protocol contretemps.

Prof George Saitoti, the Internal Security minister, called upon Prime Minister Raila Odinga to speak before Vice-President Kalonzo Musyoka, hoping to institutionalise the fiction that the Vice-President is politically senior to the Prime Minister.

Once again, the President appeared to remain above the fray by not addressing the issue as challenged by Raila.

To those unfamiliar with the politics of the last few years, the incident at the IDP tent, which has now been named ‘State House’, and the protocol flap at the stadium appeared to be totally unrelated. In fact, these events were just two sides of the same coin. As statisticians would say, they were connected not only by correlation but by causation as well.

For some reason, Kenyans, especially their political leaders, do not seem to read and appreciate the actual conditions on the ground. They neglect or ignore the correlation between their actions or omissions and political realities.

They erroneously believe that if they stick to a particular game plan long enough, the inconvenient realities will disappear. In a sense, a lot of our politicians speak and act as if they don’t live in this country.

Very poor advice

The problem of IDPs is not going to be solved overnight. The Government will not solve it by throwing billions of shillings at it. It is not going to be solved by the building of more and more police stations. It is much more complicated than that.

The President has lately been preaching to us that we should forget what happened after the last General Election and move on. If he believes that, then he is obviously being given very poor advice. We cannot afford to forget what happened, any more than the Rwandans can forget the genocide of 1994 or the Jews the Holocaust of World War II.

It is in our collective memories of the aftermath of the General Election that we shall seek, and hopefully find, our way forward. It is in these collective memories that we shall seek, and hopefully find, one sure way of cleansing our national soul.

What the President should be telling us is that we should try and forgive all those who killed our relatives, burned our houses or wronged us in any way whatsoever — not to forget what happened and why.

Fiasco

The protocol fiasco that we witnessed last week is all part of this problem. Many of our top politicians are confusing the political realities on the ground with their own fantasies and imagination.

The reality on the ground is that the Prime Minister is the second most important political player in this country. When Chief Mediator, Dr Kofi Annan, used to talk about “the two principals”, everybody understood which two men he was referring to.

At the meeting held at Sagana State Lodge which produced the final list of Cabinet ministers, the Vice-President was nowhere in sight.

Trying to confuse the obvious is merely making fools of ourselves.

The writer is a lecturer and consultant in Nairobi

Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

Negative ethnicity

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

Our ethnicity problems the result of conflicting visions

Story by KIRIRO WA NGUGI
Publication Date: 4/28/2008

THE POST-ELECTION VIOLENCE has brought to the surface deep-seated ethnic suspicions, antipathy, jealousy and outright hatred which has exploded the image of Kenya as an island of peace.

But having calmed our nerves through the formation of a grand coalition government, we now seriously risk papering over a fundamental reality: We are not “one people” as we want to wish; we are a diverse people living together in a geographic unit.

Unfortunately, the object of our multi-ethnic co-existence within a geographic space as defined by colonial powers without regard to our social cohesiveness has never been justified in clear, concise terms.

We have instead been anaesthetised into a false comfort zone sustained by a constant campaign of mere slogans proclaiming that we are one people while paradoxically admitting our cultural ethnic diversity in yet more slogans – “diversity is our strength” or “unity in diversity”.

We do not seem to have quite made up our minds as to whether we are “one people” or we are a “diverse people”. Certainly, we cannot be both!

BUT THERE’S A PERCEPTION THAT we are expected to become one people, thereby achieving a “civilised” status rather than remaining ethnically aware because that is “primitive”.

I intend to summarise below two schools of thought that need to be resolved if we are to acquire a permanent solution to the challenges of managing our diverse ethnic character.

The first and most popular vision is mounted on a perception originating from colonial brainwashing –  that modern democratic ideals are incompatible with African ethnic cohesiveness.

Our collective intellect appears to have been permanently damaged by colonialism, and we are terrified by the reality that our most potent and cohesive political tool is the tribe.

This common “wisdom” is captured in the following local newspaper editorial made a few years back but still very relevant today: “When the tribe replaces the political party as the instrument of political mobilisation in the quest for power, then it becomes the focus of rivalry, chauvinism and inevitable hostility, and from that point to Rwanda or Biafra is a very short step indeed”.

This view is especially popular among educated Africans who seem to expect, nay, demand, that in time, their ethnic Luo-ness or Kikuyu-ness shall cease to exist and therefrom shall emerge an everlasting de-ethnicitised and civilised one tribe called Kenya.

But there is another, less popular but very potent vision which argues that if there are no ethnic Luo, Maasai, Kikuyu, etc, then there will be no Kenyans either – merely Western cultural stooges claiming to be so. This vision recognises ethnicity as a critical and integral part of human society which cannot ever be wished away.

In and of itself, ethnicity is not a threat to unity; we can be different but accept to live together within a modern state so long as we understand the clear rationale why such unity is necessary.

This vision thus admits, without any misgivings whatsoever, that Kenyans inevitably vote in tribal blocs and will continue to do so. Therefore, as in most of Africa, the tribe has just replaced the political party as the instrument of political mobilisation.

The tribe is the instrument of political and social expression and will remain so for quite a while, maybe even to the end of time.

This, therefore, becomes the starting point of peaceful co-existence and must, in particular, find open recognition in the institutions of State, especially the constitutional power arrangements.

The issue that needs to be resolved is not that we are tribes; rather whether we can become “civilised” tribes with the ability to treat each other in a humane, considerate manner, always aware that our gift of ethnicity is not to be enjoyed at the detriment of the others’ similar gift.

To do this, we require a valid, sensible and clear rationale for that ‘‘civilised’’ behaviour. Unfortunately, the object of ethnic co-existence within a geographic space defined by colonial powers has never been justified in clear terms.

THIS IS THE WEAKEST LINK IN OUR adopted Western-style democracy and politicking. We have not explained to ourselves what our common endeavour as ethnic communities is, or should be. Politics in Africa has become an ethnic dog-fight, sometimes unto death as we have now witnessed in Kenya, in an attempt to place one of our own in control of all national resources.

The immediate and only rationale for a diverse people to want to live together is to maximise the advantages of the economies of scale. The size of market is therefore our first, and probably only common interest.

Ethnicity should not be despised, nor wished away but rather acknowledged openly as a means of better managing our society. The way forward for us has the same challenges and rationale as the formation of the European Union; the size of market and economic outcomes for culturally diverse peoples.

This is the most viable intellectual foundation for Kenya as a state; an “Ethnic Union” formed entirely for better economies of scale and which does not demand Luo, Kamba, or Kikuyu cease to be who they are. Diversity then truly becomes our strength.
 
Mr Ngugi is a businessman and a former delegate at Bomas.

 
Write to the author

Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

RAILA IN GERMANY FOR MEDICAL REASONS

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

Grand plot to undermine PM

Published on April 28, 2008, 12:00 am

By Standard Team

Claims of a “grand plot” to undermine Prime Minister Raila Odinga in Parliament touched off bitter exchanges within ODM on a day PNU also had its missiles trained on the Orange party.

The tussles gathered intensity as the PM jetted out of the country last night for Germany to undergo what sources close to ODM described as a “brief medical procedure”.

The alleged “grand plot” against Raila has been linked to MPs — a number of them from ODM — who are pushing for a Grand Opposition in a Parliament that has no Leader of the Official Opposition.

Sensationally, the alleged plot has also been linked to the raging protocol wars between the Raila and his brigade on the one hand, and Vice-President, Mr Kalonzo Musyoka, and PNU leaders sympathetic to him, on the other.

In contention is exactly who is second to President Kibaki in the pecking order. Politicians in the Kibaki camp maintain that the VP is his principal assistant, and therefore, his second in command.

But Raila loyalists say in the National Accord and Reconciliation Act, which gave birth to the Grand Coalition, Raila and Kibaki share executive power equally.

There was no word from President Kibaki, who some leaders say should clear the air on a matter that assumed near-comical dimensions during the Rift Valley peace tour.

On his part, Kalonzo downplayed the pecking order standoff between him and Raila terming it “a small matter”.

“I have no problem with the PM over the pecking order. Our determination to help President Kibaki serve Kenyans is what is being misunderstood as a struggle between the two of us,” the VP, who was speaking on Sunday at Thika High School when he launched a free one-week eye and throat clinic, clarified.

Plot to undermine PM

 

But claiming to “lift the lid” on the alleged plot at the weekend, Dr Oburu Oginga, the Finance Assistant minister, Bondo MP and Raila’s brother, claimed that the objective was to portray the PM as inconsequential.

He also alleged that the plot was aimed at cutting ODM’s numerical strength in Parliament and, by extension, Raila’s to throw the reform agenda into disarray.

“There is nothing like Grand Opposition. What these MPs are doing is joining hands with our enemies to cause trouble for the ODM leadership,” Oburu said as the simmering discontent in the party burst out in the open.

Oburu appeared to point at a two-pronged assault on the PM to be mounted in and outside Parliament. Already, up to 75 MPs have signed up a petition pushing for the Grand Opposition, a number of them in ODM.

And, with loyalties seemingly already divided, and with five crucial by-elections in the offing, ODM’s leverage in Parliament could be yanked away. This shifting of loyalties may now mean ODM has 106 MPs only on paper against PNU’s 98.

“This is an attempt to form another political party through the backdoor to undermine ODM leadership. ODM MPs should be focused on helping Raila discharge his duties effectively,” said Oburu.

Oburu, together with Lands minister, Mr James Orengo, Assistant minister, Prof Ayiecho Olweny, and Nominated MP, Mr Musa Sirma, clashed with MPs, Mr Fred Outa (ODM, Nyando) and Mr Pollyns Ochieng’ (ODM, Nyakach), over backbenchers’ opposition plan.

The two said they would, together with others, step up campaigns to constitute opposition in Parliament to check on the Grand Coalition Government.

But Orengo, Oburu and Olweny dismissed the MPs fronting for the grand opposition as self-seekers targeting packages that come with the office of the Leader of Official Opposition in Parliament.

The MPs were speaking at Obago Primary School in Muhoroni at the weekend during Olweny’s homecoming ceremony following his appointment to as an assistant minister.

But Mr Ababu Namwamba, the Budalang’i ODM MP and party Parliamentary Group Secretary, dismissed Oburu’s assertion that party legislators fronting for a grand opposition were out to undermine Raila.

“It is clear in the Constitution that the opposition in Parliaments checks on Government, not an individual. I don’t understand why my friend Oburu, who has been in Parliament for all these years, cannot understand this,” said Namwamba.

The MP added that the Constitution does not describe Government as Raila, saying “Oburu should stop his blind loyalty to his brother and allow MPs to correct him where he goes wrong”.

And as the standoff between ODM MPs over the Grand Coalition unravelled, the protocol wars would not just go away.

PM powerful than VP

 

Yesterday, Justice and Constitutional Affairs minister, Ms Martha Karua, said the Constitution was clear on the pecking order in Government.

She said the power sharing accord enshrined in the Constitution clearly states the pecking order and the specific roles.

“There is no abuse of protocol. The Constitution is very clear on the role of the President, the Vice-President and the Prime Minister,” Karua, who was speaking at Isiolo Stadium during the homecoming party of her Livestock Development counterpart, Dr Mohammed Kuti, said on Saturday.

The Gichugu MP was backed by Kuti and Assistant minister, Mr Danson Mungatana, and MPs Mr Erastus Mureithi (Ol Kalau) and Mr M’Itha M’Mithiaru (Igembe North).

Kuti, however, pointed out: “The Grand Coalition between the two principals was based on good faith. The same should be reflected by all the MPs in the coalition.”

But speaking on the telephone, former Kabete MP and Safina leader, Mr Paul Muite, said: “You cannot equate the Prime minister to the VP. According to the Constitution, despite the VP being the principal assistant of the President, he has no executive powers as the PM. The PM has more powers than the VP.”

However, Nairobi Metropolitan Development minister, Mr Mutula Kilonzo, and Kibwezi MP, Prof Philip Kaloki, said Kenyans looked upon the three leaders — President Kibaki, Kalonzo and Raila — to provide servant leadership.

They said the protocol issue should not be allowed to disrupt service delivery to Kenyans who cared less about who-is-who in the pecking order.

 

Posted in News | 2 Comments »

ON STRIKE KALONZO TEAM REJECTED

Posted by SG on April 28, 2008

Face-off looms as VP’s team rejected

Story by NATION Team
Publication Date: 4/28/2008

The crisis in Kenya’s correctional institutions was set to deepen Sunday after striking prison warders rejected a team set up to look into their grievances.

Vice-President Kalonzo Musyoka is shown bathrooms shared by warders at Thika prison when he toured the correctional facility on Sunday. Photo/ZACHARIA CHILISWA

The warders also asked colleagues to remove their families from prison quarters in readiness for possible violent confrontation with the authorities.

Police also announced that they were ready for a face-off with the warders who could be armed.

Vice-President Kalonzo Musyoka appointed his predecessor, Mr Moody Awori, to head the eight-member team which includes former prisons commissioner Abraham Kamakil.

Living conditions

But Sunday, warders in 93 prisons across the country claimed that Mr Awori did nothing to uplift their living conditions when he was in charge.

Labour minister John Munyes and Cotu secretary-general Francis Atwoli also rejected the Awori team, saying it was not representative.

Mr Munyes regretted that his ministry had been left out of the team, yet it had the mandate to handle all labour issues between employers and workers.

He called for reforms in the prisons department that would focus on the warders.

Said Mr Atwoli: “How can Mr Musyoka appoint Mr Awori to head the committee to look into the warders’ grievances while he was part of the problem? He was more interested in reforming the prisoners at the expense of  warders.”  The Cotu boss asked Mr Musyoka to reconstitute the committee and include representatives from the trade unions, the Federation of Kenya Employers and the Ministry of Labour.

The warders also accused Mr Awori and Mr Kamakil of being more interested in  improving the welfare of prisoners at their expense.

Families

Leaders of the go-slow, which started on Thursday, told their colleagues  via short text messages (SMS): “To our loyal colleagues living with their families in these rags, you are advised to arrange and transport your families home before Wednesday as the war is just about to start. No retreat, no surrender.”

On Sunday, Mr Musyoka came face-to-face with warders’ squalid living conditions when he visited Thika prison.

“The conditions of living of both prisoners and warders are deplorable but we are committed to improve them.”

He appealed to warders  to resume their duties today as the Government awaits a report by the Awori team.

The warders grievances include risk allowance which is being  enjoyed by the regular and administration police, non-payment of stipend for their participation in quelling post-election violence, and failure to supply them with uniforms.

They also questioning the whereabouts of Sh25 million deducted from their pay for the construction of Magereza Academy in Naivasha since the project  is yet to start.

Justice minister Martha Karua said the grievances were genuine and were “part of the things that have been neglected for years by former regimes”.  She said Kibaki had been in power for ‘‘short time compared to the decades of fornmer regimes.’’

Speaking in Nyeri, the minister  asked the officers to give the Government time to address the issue.

The strike has adversely affected the justice system as remand prisoners have not been taken to court for the hearing of their cases. Police spokesman  Eric Kiraithe said they had put in place contingency measures to deal with possible public protests by warders.

It emerged Sunday that the Government failed to respond to warnings from the prison authorities over a  crisis fuelled by the Sh10,000 stipend.

Sent letters

Documents obtained by the Nation show that the Commissioner of Prisons, Mr Gilbert Omondi, sent letters to Office of the President and the VP’s office over the matter.

“There is rising discontent among members of our staff because of consideration for payment of risk allowance to the police officers only although the Ministry of State for Public Service had information from my office about the matter,’’   Mr Omondi  says in one of his letters to OP.

Reports by Kenneth Ogosia, Dave Opiyo, Muchemi Wachira, Oliver Musembi and Odhiambo Orlale

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

NDURA WARUINGI OURS CLAIM MUNGIKI

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

http://bichage.wordpress.com/2008/02/14/ndura-waruinge-and-maina-njenga-are-still-mungiki/

Christian convert and PNU politician Ndura Waruinge and imprisoned mungiki chief Maina Njenga have not “properly deserted mungiki”, we can now report. A leader of the gang in Central Nairobi, a Mathenge (Mnyama) was asked by a reporter why his dreaded gang had not beheaded the duo. His answer was curt, “They are alive because we know they have not moved, there are clear structures on how resignations of top leaders are handled, look they were once Muslims remember that conversion? Now they are Christians, maybe tomorrow they will be Hindu but the bottom line is that they are still part of us”.

From the interview, it emerged that some of mungiki’s followers are the educated middle-class who contribute a whooping KShs 2 billion a year to sustain the gang. Consequences for defaulting are scary, the gang says.

Asked whether they kill people, Mathenge retorted, “True we have been killing people but you have to understand us, even God in the Old Testament killed people who did not toe the line of the Law. We have been killing defectors, and those who refuse to pay their dues for our services and that will not stop”.

Asked how many mungiki members are in Kenya and abroad, “We had our last National Convention in April 2007 in Thogoto and we realized we had recruited 45,000 new members we are now about 2.8 million, of course excluding Women and Children”.

The group is currently led by one Joe Waiganjo (General) and draws membership from some of the politicians in parliament.

Meanwhile, a plan by the outlawed Mungiki, a sect which is slowly transforming into an Italian like Mafia, was to blame for most of the crimes committed in early 2007 in the East African nation, a confidential twenty-four page police report indicates. The report details a shocking blow-blow account of a Mungiki that is not only running real estate and transport businesses but one that is now boasting of making a number of poor people instant millionaires and one that was preparing to sponsor a number of candidates to parliament in last year’s general elections – which they did.

The report says that the crime wave that had hit the country at the time the report was compiled under the spotlight was directly funded by the Mungiki and is intentionally aimed at the rich and prominent in the society and police officers.The report even lists recently fallen Kenya’s most wanted Criminal Simon Matheri Ikeere as one of the prominent members of the dreaded cult. “Out of the 26 criminals whose photo’s police have circulated over the last six months, 18 belong to the Mungiki,” the report says.

So organized is the Mungiki, that the report approximates the net worth of the outlawed religious sect at Shs. 4.5 billion as at January 15 this year. Interestingly, the report says the Mungiki are currently preparing to have its first budget in May this year – a month before the National budget usually presented by Finance Ministers in parliament. Just like any other serious Mafia organization, the Mungiki runs six armouries – five less than what the state runs, across the country. The headquarters, the report says, is in Laikipia and that’s where all the sources of weapons direct their donations.

“The Mungiki Laikipia armory is large and runs about 15 feet deep, those who steal guns from the police are rewarded with ranks within the organization and are branded heroes,” the report reveals.Other armouries are in Dandora, Tigoni area, Kayole, Njiru and Kitengela. “Each armoury exists for a reason; the Tigoni one is a back-up for highway crime, while Kayole and Njiru exist so as to offer refuge to gangsters and those commanding the transport sector.” “The Kitengela armoury is the main source of weapons and manpower to spread fear and panic, basically it is meant to organize and dispatch assignments,” the report reads.

The sources of weapons for the organization has been directly linked to the beef business where guns are wrapped together with the meat as it makes its way from North-Eastern to the country, other sources include th Oromo Liberation Front in Ethiopia and North Uganda.

In the armouries, the main weapons available are AK 47’s with a cache of bullets and G3 rifles.“The ultimate goal,” reads the report stamped highly confidential, “is to make sure that both the Police Commissioner and the Minister for Internal Security are sacked.

“The attack on foreigners is so as to affect the booming tourism industry and to increase the pressure of the sackings from abroad countries housed in Kenya, attacks on the rich and the prominent is a strategy to unify Kenyans around the same cause, while that strategy of killing police officers is meant to scare the law enforcers, and those are all characteristics of a Mafia Organization,” the report chillingly reads on.

“They have established a clear broad network and with the laws on money laundering still very weak they are able to access lots of money through charity like events and others directly from Kenyans with a die hard association with the group, a channel that cannot be stopped, because they educate hundreds of children and even run three credible children’s home,” the report says.

Mungiki, the report further reveals has already adopted a flag that’s coloured white, yellow, green, red and black – hues associated with the sect.

Links are also being drawn to an international organization the Universal Miracle Centre, little information about the mother body were forthcoming by the time of going to press. “The resurgence of the sect comes after a failed attempt to revive under the guise of the National Youth Alliance Party,” the report further reads.

Young unemployed people are lured into Mungiki through practical pledges of employment and life changing fortune making assignments, “graduates pass through a rite that involves ingesting human urine and umbilical cords, before undergoing a public baptism, where English (or Christian) names are dropped in favour of authentic names”.

Elaborate Ritual

The report further details how conversion to Mungiki happens, “Initially held at their shrine in Karandi area of Laikipia District, the oathing ceremony is an elaborate process, which begins late in the evening, goes on through the night to end at dawn.”

Black sheep and goats are slaughtered and their blood mixed with some mixture said to be made out of wild plant roots. Other independent sources explained to our reporters that, “Traditional Kikuyu beer, Muratina, whose main component is honey is served in plenty as the initiates engage in singing and chanting slogan in praise of their gods and the movement.”

Paraphernalia, which include walking sticks painted in red, green, black and white, gourds and small tobacco containers are passed around to members and a flag in the same colours is normally hosted outside the shrine. “We are Mungiki and we shall stick together and guard the secrets of our sect. We shall protect one another and remain united under our leaders…” the initiates chant as they sip a bloody concoction that is passed around to everyone present. They also sing traditional songs.

“Roast meat is also passed around to members who take bites in turns after their leaders, and tobacco, in small containers, is passed around for members to sniff,” says a former member who requested anonymity.

The man, who co-ordinated Mungiki activities in Rift Valley since the sect was founded until it was declared illegal, says the aim of the elaborate ritual is to unify the group. “All we wanted to achieve was strong unity and to be identified by the society,” he says. The sole purpose of the oath, he says, is to ensure that the initiates abide to our doctrines of coming together to form a society that respects the Kikuyu culture and the ancient practices.

As morning comes, the new initiates are “baptised” in the wee hours of the morning at a dam near the shrine. The then sect spiritual leader Maina Njenga conducted the ceremonies. The converts are immersed in the murky waters before passing over a goatskin, which is spread on the ground where the spiritual leader stood. The sad thing about those who joined the sect after being coerced was that there was no turning back after the oath, our source revealed.

“Anyone who joined the sect would be allowed to know all the secrets including our sources of funds our operations and other internal matters. That is why some people were killed once they denounced the sect,” he reveals. There is no turning back once you are a true Mungiki, he says, adding that no one has ever performed a reversal ritual.

“This explains why those who join us disappear from the public domain once they feel like not continuing to be members,” he explains.

Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment »

THE ORIGINS OF MUNGIKI

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

THE ORIGINS OF MUNGIKI, THEIR OBJECTIVES.

http://www.bluegecko.org/kenya/tribes/kikuyu/articles-mungiki.htm

Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

RAILA IN THE FOOTSPTEPS OF HIS FATHER

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

NEWS EXTRA

In the footsteps of my father

Story by CLAY MUGANDA
Publication Date: 4/27/2008

As is the tradition in many African societies in which the father was the homestead leader, it is the first son who is the heir-apparent or the one who assumes the old man’s mantle.

Prime Minister Raila Odinga addresses the media at a past conference in Nairobi. Photos/ FILE

But here in Kenya, one man is defying the tradition. He has not only overshadowed his elder brother but also acts as if he is the one on which the father bestowed all political blessings.

The man is Raila Amolo Odinga, the resilient, tactical schemer who is feared as much as he is respected by friend and foe alike.

Unlike his elder brother, Oburu Odinga,  Kenya’s second prime minister since independence personifies what his father, Jaramogi Oginga Odinga, stood for. And even though death nipped Mr Odinga Senior’s ambition in the bud of leading this country, Mr Odinga Jnr has succeeded where his father failed, even if in a position lower than that of the President.

Jaramogi was equally held in awe and held the Luo under his spell, so much so that whomever he campaigned for in the community was sure to make it to Parliament. And he had funny ways of “endorsing” candidates. Unlike the modern-day politicians who endorse candidates at political rallies, Mr Odinga Snr only visited his preferred candidate’s area to tell the people to pass his regards to him. And the person had the ticket.

His word was more than law among the Luo, and his powers bordered on the supernatural. The people of Luo Nyanza were charmed by stories of his powers and exploits. Boys and girls grew up knowing that Jaramogi Oginga Odinga was the be-all and end-all of Kenyan politics — an invincible politician who was always ready to fight for the people’s rights and those of the down-trodden.

He was feared about as much as he was respected, and if he told a Luo politician not to contest an election, that was it. Whoever went against his word was doomed to failure — at least in politics. But although the political establishment did not like this state of affairs, it did little to reduce the faith the people had in him. The government’s  determination to tame him only strengthened this faith.

He was detained several times by both the Kenyatta and the Moi administrations, but each time he came out stronger and more determined to continue with the struggle. There is not much difference between what Jaramogi went through and what his son has encountered in his political life.

A known fighter who commands fanatical support in Luo Nyanza, Mr Odinga Jnr is not only living his father’s dream, but also following in his footsteps.

Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

Mungiki runs deep and wide

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

Mungiki runs deep and wide

Published on April 27, 2008, 12:00 am

By Sunday Standard writer

When a Mungiki adherent appeared on television two weeks ago and admitted that he would kill if his group asked him to, he was merely being faithful to the laws of the sect.

It is admissions like these that have forced even residents of areas hard hit by the Mungiki terror to question whether the guns-and-batons approach of the Government will eliminate the group.

Positions differ sharply, even within the police force, on the better way between dialogue and the gun, to deal with the terror group.

Some high-level security officers say Mungiki is a political tool, and agree with the sect’s assertions at times that there are politicians paying up periodically, with whom they have no problem.

“If you have never joined Mungiki, you need not worry. They know whom they want and the hunted know why,” said a senior policeman.

Police and intelligence officials believe a number of politicians from Central Kenya have had dealings with the sect, and some continue to do so.

Another retired intelligence officer says Mungiki has also incorporated prominent businessmen and some of those they target could owe them something.

“When Mungiki set out to burn vehicles, they don’t just pick any. They know the vehicles they are looking for. When they arrive, they don’t ask questions, they set it on fire and move, leaving other vehicles intact. That should tell you something,” the retired officer said.

After years of terror by the sect despite frequent police crackdown, those who live daily with the Mungiki threat think the authorities should try a new way. They think negotiation could work better than guns.

Defiance

Scholarly studies done on this group appear to favour this line too, concluding that the sect runs deep and is much older than the authorities appear to understand.

Studies show that feeding on failures of the Government from around 1987 to date, Mungiki runs deep and wide, and its defiance is part of its code of rules.

Key among the rules Mungiki holds dear, according various researches, some academic, is that members never surrender to their enemies.

Mungiki rules also stipulate that a member never betrays his or her comrades, and never leaves a comrade in trouble. They had better die together.

Mungiki members have sworn never to fear death, “for it is natural” and every adherent is sworn to be “available at the time of need.”

In the sect, cultural beliefs have blended with religion, politics and thirst for money by members, creating a fearsome organisation some now believe cannot be brought down by the gun.

“This is a social problem that requires a social approach,” says Mr Esau Kioni, a former aide to President Mwai Kibaki and resident of Murang’a.

The former State House official, who unsuccessfully contested the Mathioya parliamentary seat last year, likens the sect to the thangari grass common in Central Province.

“You cut thangari at the top, and clear all the leaves, but the root continues to grow underground and the whole grass resurfaces far from where you first cut it,” Kioni says. “That is what we have been doing with Mungiki. We have been clearing the thangari at the top but the roots have continued to grow underground. It is not a solution.”

He adds: “We need a commission of social scientists to come up with solutions.”

Although police believe Mungiki is not as big as it has been portrayed, arguing that politicians have bolstered it, other researches tell a different story.

Garbage collectors

When the Nairobi City Council failed to collect garbage in the 1980s to around 2003, youths teamed up as garbage collectors, a task they still perform. Those garbage collectors were either Mungiki members or later became members.

The city council no longer collects garbage from households. That task has fallen on private hands, and the young man who knocks on your gate at the weekend may well be a Mungiki member, transacting a legitimate business.

The car washer at your chosen spot may also be a Mungiki member. Studies, some filed in library archives, show that Mungiki have heavily invested in hawking, car washing and neighbourhood or estate security teams.

Some of the businesses are legitimate and feed on the fears of residents and failures of the system.

One study shows Mungiki had a field day in Nairobi, Central Province and Rift Valley between 1988 and 1994, enabling it to spread to parts of Eastern, Coast and Nyanza provinces.

The Government attempted to crack down on the sect only around December 1994, arresting 63 suspected members in Laikipia.

And it was not until early 2003 that police destroyed the movement’s headquarters in Ng’arua, Laikipia, where it also has two shrines at Seria and Mwenje.

Military style

Within that time, says another study, the sect had established links with some Pentecostal churches in Laikipia and other parts of Central Province.

In January 1991, a Pentecostal bishop who remains one of its counsellors to date, hosted them in Murang’a.

Probably, it is because of this early support by a Murang’a church that explains the heavy Mungiki presence in that region.

In Maragua, for instance, the sect was said to have more than 200 platoons spread across 10 branches and 33 sub branches manned by more than 2,000 militiamen by early 2000.

Here, like everywhere else, says one study, Mungiki organised itself military style, in platoons.

A platoon comprises 10 militiamen, each with a personal registration number. That organisational structure is replicated elsewhere, but mostly in Central Province.

The ethnic clashes that broke out in 1991 stopped Mungiki’s spread in areas like Kuresoi, Eldama Ravine, Eldoret, Kericho, Kakamega and Kisii, where its members had already set up base.

When the land clashes of 1991 checked the sect’s march westwards to the Rift Valley and surrounding provinces, its members discreetly moved to Nairobi.

One study found them establishing base in Nairobi’s Kahawa West in early 1992, hosted by a woman in Kamae village.

From there, the sect began to spread its message door-to-door. They hoisted their first flags in Nairobi and Ng’arua on December 12, 1992.

Such activities, researchers say, show sophistication and dedication that contradicts the notion that the sect can be wiped out by terror.

Even within the security circles, the notion that Mungiki is everywhere and there is no way of identifying who is a member and who is not, has gained ground.


Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

Straight talking hon Karua tells it as it is

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

Straight talking Karua tells it as it is

Published on April 27, 2008, 12:00 am

By Oscar Obonyo

Justice and Constitutional Affairs Minister talks about the deputy premier’s slot, pecking order between the PM and the VP and on her presidential ambitions

Sunday Standard: You looked like the favourite for the slot of Deputy Prime Minister from the PNU side, with advantage in terms of political experience, your role in the Kofi Annan-led talks and on the gender aspect. How did it slip through your fingers and do you feel defrauded?

KARUA: My credentials notwithstanding, the appointment of the DPM was at the discretion of the President and he made his choice. For me, serving as a DPM is not an entitlement and I would rather not worry about it, but serve my people as MP for Gichugu and in any other capacity the President deems fit.

SS: President Kibaki seems to have taken you by surprise when he signed the National Accord and Reconciliation Act with the Prime Minister, contrary to the information that had been filtering through from the PNU negotiating team. Did you see it coming?

KARUA: There were areas we could not negotiate on. Albeit the push. We refused to guess the size of the Cabinet and how the slots would be shared. We had no mandate on certain areas and that is why we referred the matter to the two principals and I am glad they resolved the issue.

SS: You have an additional docket of national cohesion. What does it entail and what challenges do you anticipate?

KARUA: The wordings “national cohesion” are self-explanatory and we are developing mechanism and programmes to move forward as a united nation. We can only move together and make the necessary progress as a Government if we read from the same hymnbook.

SS: This does not seem to be the case, at least going by the tension between the PM and VP, revolving around protocol.

KARUA: What this shows is that as MPs, we have not read and internalised the Constitution. While enacting the National Accord and Reconciliation Act 2008, we must interpret it in harmony with existing statutes. Whatever positions we hold, we must learn to appreciate and accommodate one another. I can only say the start has been bumpy, but we need to accelerate our speed to deliver as a team on the promises we the electorate.

SS: Even as you resettle the displaced, do you plan to address the case of those languishing in jail for allegedly participating in post-election violence?

KARUA: ODM has demanded their release, but we cannot allow a situation where suspects are released on the demands of politicians. This is tantamount to abrogating the rule of law. The much we can do is to quicken the hearing of pending cases.

SS: Separately, ODM claims to have been short-changed in the power-sharing deal. Do you agree and does PNU feel the same?

KARUA: It is not fair to apportion blames on the issue. Since it is the two principals who made the Cabinet appointments, those dissatisfied with the way their leaders negotiated should treat it as an in-house matter. Even then, is it logical that anytime I disagree with a decision my leader makes, I throw tantrums? We must learn to respect the chain of command.

SS: What are your views on the proposed Grand Opposition?

KARUA: You cannot have a grand coalition government and a grand opposition at the same time. This negates the spirit and the statutes of the National Accord and Reconciliation Act 2008.

In creating the Office of Prime Minister it is clear that, that the holder of the office will be leader of a political party that has the majority MPs. If we allow an opposition arrangement then no single party will have a clear majority in Parliament, yet this accord is the very threshold of the new political dispensation.

SS: Is your quest for the presidency still on?

KARUA: Of course, and most serious. But for now, I am busy serving my constituents and other Kenyans. And I must add that everything I choose to do, I give it my full attention.

SS: Finally, mheshimiwa, are you tough, firm and non-compromising? If not, why do you think some Kenyans perceive you so?

KARUA: Those of us who have the courage to voice our stand for what we believe in are perceived wrongly and criticised for all manner of things. I will not be hypocritical because in leadership one must stand for what they believe in. I am what I am today because of my principles.


Posted in Articles | Leave a Comment »

Kenya: Dilemma a one-man Opposition

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

Dilemma as House braces for a one-man Opposition

Published on April 27, 2008, 12:00 am

By Oscar Obonyo

Lugari MP Mr Cyrus Jirongo — the sole opposition leader recognised by the Tenth Parliament — has a tough job.

He has to keep the Grand Coalition Government on its toes, but as his backbench colleagues rightly argue, it is an enormous task the Kaddu chairman can hardly perform alone.

Now, backbench colleagues from coalition party members, Party of National Unity (PNU), Orange Democratic Movement (ODM), ODM-Kenya, Kanu, among others, are insisting on lending Jirongo a hand.

But the MPs’ “good gesture” is not helped by the fact that they “offered assistance” a day after President Kibaki named a Cabinet of the Grand Coalition Government, and only after missing out on the same.

Their case is further complicated by parliamentary legislation that only recognises Official Opposition with at least 30 MPs in the House.

Jirongo is the only Kaddu MP and to get the numbers those keen on “assisting” him play opposition chief, may have to forfeit their seats and seek a new mandate.

But Francis Linturi (Igembe South, Kanu), who has moved the Motion to have the controversial issue debated, is afraid that the 65-plus MPs not serving as ministers will be denied the constitutional right to assemble and associate freely under the Grand Opposition.

He argues that Parliament should make the necessary legislation to pave way for a grand opposition coalition in the same way it did the Grand Coalition Government.

But Justice, Constitutional Affairs and National Cohesion Minister, Ms Martha Karua is categorical: “You cannot have a Grand Coalition and a grand opposition. This negates the spirit and the statutes of the National Accord and Reconciliation Act 2008. In creating the Office of Prime Minister it is very clear that the holder of the office will be leader of a political party that has the majority MPs.”

She argues that if such a scenario was to be allowed then no single party would have a clear majority in Parliament, yet this accord is the very threshold of the new political dispensation.

The Constitutional Affairs Minister’s position notwithstanding, a determined Linturi told The Sunday Standard that, the Speaker had approved the Motion and the same was to be forwarded to the House Business Committee.

The HBC meets on Tuesday and, depending on how it prioritises its Motions, the Linturi-private member’s Motion could come to the floor of the House as early as Wednesday.

And Linturi adds another twist to the saga with claims that those in Government are dead scared that the backbenchers might form another political party to upstage their party bosses come 2012.

Indeed, these are some of the possible scenarios and realities that the political leadership of PNU, ODM, ODM-Kenya and Kanu are aware of.

Already, leaders of Safina, which is affiliated to PNU, have expressed interest in pulling out of the coalition. Safina politicians, say they have been short-changed in Cabinet appointments.

But well aware of this possible threat, The Sunday Standard has established that PNU and ODM are plotting to “adequately accommodate” the dissenting voices in their midst.

Already some of their key members are lined up for slots in the Parliamentary Service Commission — a crucial administrative organ.

Among those being touted for positions are PNU’s Joseph Lekuton (Laisamis) and Jamleck Kamau (Kigumo). ODM’s slots could go to Chris Okemo (Nambale), Charles Cheruiyot (Kuresoi) and Gideon Mungaro (Malindi).

The 10-member commission is the top administrative organ of Parliament and has powers to hire and fire parliamentary staff as well as determining the employees’ salaries.

House Speaker, Kenneth Marende and Vice-President Kalonzo are automatic members.

Dismissing the goings on as selfish driven political games, Nairobi lawyer and civil rights activist, Mr Harun Ndubi points out that as an individual MP, one has every right to hold the Government accountable from either side of the floor of the House, while in the backbench or even from the front bench.

The Constitution, which factors in the existence of multi-party democracy, accords the Leader of Official Opposition a host of privileges similar to those enjoyed by a Cabinet minister.

Over and above this, the opposition leaders chair parliamentary watchdog outfits, including the Parliamentary Accounts Committee and the Public Investments Committee.

Although the quest for Leader of Official Opposition initially attracted the interest of a sizeable number of legislators, some like Okemo, have withdrawn from the chase.

Nonetheless, Okemo points out that owing to what is “clearly emerging as a case of being short-changed”, ODM would have declined sharing a Government with “illegitimate winners in PNU” and instead offered solid opposition in Parliament.

Stating that it is in the interest of the Kenyan people, Linturi is optimistic that the Bill will be passed with “little or no hitch” at all.

Linturi warns that the absence of Opposition spells doom for the Kenyan public, an argument that Ndubi refutes. The lawyer points out that some of the biggest economic scams facing the country now like the Goldenberg and Anglo Leasing were in fact executed at a time when there was “one of the most active and alert opposition in Parliament”.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »

No deal yet in ODM camp

Posted by SG on April 27, 2008

No deal yet’ in ODM camp

Published on April 27, 2008, 12:00 am

By Oscar Obonyo

The “small warning” by Environment minister John Michuki about the proverbial camel that displaced its host from his hut, might have persuaded the ODM brigade to drop its initial power-sharing demands.

“Our ODM partners should not be like the proverbial camel which was allowed to put its head into a hut only to push the whole body in, displacing the occupant,” said Michuki at the height of the Cabinet composition impasse.

ODM later dropped its “unrealistic demands” over portfolio balance and a 50-50 sharing of civil service and ambassadorial appointments. Maybe this compromise was weighty enough and the recent appointments of Permanent Secretaries could just be the final straw that broke the camel’s back.

President Kibaki’s choice of permanent secretaries, made public last Monday, immediately met furious reactions from the ODM wing of Government.

Some party leaders now lament that they were not consulted. They were enraged that as in the sharing of Cabinet slots, they were outwitted again.

Tension in the Orange camp was heightened by this week’s developments in the Rift Valley during the tour by President Kibaki and Prime Minister Raila Odinga of camps for the displaced.

During the three-day tour, PNU allied ministers and the Provincial Administration lined up Raila to address rallies ahead of Vice-President Kalonzo Musyoka and President Kibaki. ODM MPs view the apparent breach of protocol as a direct affront on ODM, and a scheme to belittle the Premier’s Office.

All these factors cast a dark shadow on the future of the Grand Coalition Government.

While Kibaki’s PNU is convinced a deal was struck with the reconstitution of the Cabinet and appointment of PSs, Raila’s side believes it has been short-changed and there is “no deal yet”.

With the numerous challenges ahead, including cracking the thorny issue of IDPs and delivering a new constitution by next February, it is unlikely much will be achieved under the present atmosphere.

Justice and Constitutional Affairs minister, Ms Martha Karua, who has been handed the additional docket of “national cohesion” is equally concerned about the state of affairs.

“We can only make the necessary progress as a Government if we read from the same Hymn book,” she says.

The Gichugu MP argues that since the two principals made the power-sharing deal and appointments together, those dissatisfied should treat it as an in-house matter in their respective parties as PNU or ODM.

It is probably on this basis that ODM is auditing itself. One source partly blames newly appointed PS to the Prime Minister’s Office, Dr Mohammed Isakhakia, for the debacle. He claims that the ODM official, whom the party mandated to discuss ODM’s list of PSs with Head of Civil Service, Francis Muthaura, returned empty-handed.

“Eventually, Isakhakia told us Muthaura had dropped some of our nominees on grounds of pending graft charges, among other excuses.

“But all these could have been cooked up, and what is curious is that the sole person who ended up appointed from ODM was Isakhakia himself,” laments the party official.

ODM strongholds

The Sunday Standard has since established that among those ODM had wanted appointed were varsity dons, Prof Peter Wanyande, Prof Jacqueline Oduol, Canada-based lawyer Miguna Miguna, the party’s senior communications official, Kibisu Kabatesi, and former provincial administrator Andrew Mondoh. ODM is reported to have negotiated for 17 slots.

Nonetheless, the party officials maintain that PNU cheated them in the appointments. They claim some of the PSs purported to have been nominated by ODM are “strangers” to the party.

“Judging from their names, one would imagine they are allied to ODM since they hail from our strongholds. The truth is that they are heavily PNU-friendly,” said a source. The case of Dr Ludeki Chweya, thought to have eaten up an ODM PS slot, features prominently. Chweya, who hails from Western Kenya, that heavily supported ODM in the elections, was an operative of Kalonzo’s ODM-Kenya party.

“Although others like Sammy Kirui hail from the ODM strongholds in the Rift Valley, the party had nothing to do with their appointments,” says another official.

Yet another case is Attorney-General, Amos Wako. Despite being in Government for the last 22 years and perceived to be on the PNU side, Wako was used as a ploy to lock out ODM from several appointments including the Cabinet slot that eluded Nambale MP, Mr Chris Okemo. Both Okemo and Wako hail from Nambale.

But the exclusion of Okemo, who has previously served in the Finance and Energy portfolios, is not isolated. In the wider Meru and Embu PNU zones, leaders are equally crying foul over what they consider an imbalance in the sharing out of Cabinet slots among PNU legislators.

Barely two days before the naming of the Cabinet, Energy minister, Mr Kiraitu Murungi, warned that it would not be “business as usual” if Kibaki did not accord the community an additional Cabinet slot. And in Rift Valley, PNU politicians sent out a similar message. Laikipia East MP Maina Kiunjuri even became emotional. He scoffed at certain ministries like Gender and Children, saying he was better off serving in the Water and Irrigation ministry in an assistant capacity.

“Sasa ukinipatia Gender and Children, watoto nitafanya nao nini (If you appoint me Gender and Children’s Affairs minister, just what will I do with the children)?” he posed sarcastically in an apparent swipe at the newly elected Nyeri Town MP, Mrs Esther Murugi, who holds the docket.

A three-term MP, Kiunjuri who has been a strong Kibaki ally, is one of the Central MPs irked by the composition of the Cabinet.

Cabinet slots

Kiunjuri is among those who believed they deserved a Cabinet slot. Little wonder, Murugi, a first-term MP, has become an easy target of attack by some unhappy legislators.

The other principal in the Grand Coalition, Raila, faces an even more difficult task, particularly from South Rift MPs. At least five MPs from the Kipsigis community recently held a meeting in Kericho, during which they announced that they might get an alternative party to seek future coalitions. Dr Julius Kones (Konoin), Mr Isaac Ruto (Chepalungu), Mr Franklin Bett (Bureti), Mr Magerer Lang’at (Kipkelion) and Mr Zakayo Cheruiyot (Kuresoi) are furious that their counterparts in the North Rift got the lion’s share of the five ministries allocated to ODM in the region.

To stem an eminent fallout in their respective camps, Kibaki and Raila have resorted to the “mkate nusu (half loaf)” argument. They state that there is not enough room for all because they were compelled to share the spoils.

In the midst of the two principals, who shared between themselves close to nine million votes, is Kalonzo who hardly managed a million votes. But true to his campaign “prophecy” of nitapitia katikati yao (I will pass between Kibaki and Raila), he is reaping from the political impasse with no mkate nusu headache.

Posted in News | Leave a Comment »